My version is (probably) overkill, but I figured too many was easier to work with than too few.
As for which is ‘better’ between surface mount and conventional LED packages, it really is a matter of preference.
As I keep repeating, the surface mount packages are dramatically thinner and frequently have a flat or near flat top.
That made it easier for me because I could make a one sided circuit board, solder everything to it, lay it in a piece of aluminum U-channel, and slide that over the edge of my acrylic...and I was basically running...The U channel I found was not an exact snug fit over my acrylic...but once I tucked the roscoe & such under the edge, I was able to jam a piece of thin plastic edging like that used for fiberglass wallboard in and it wedged the whole assembly tightly in place, and with the roscoe tensioned so it doesn’t get ‘floppy’ if I make the screen vertical.
Performancewise, there should be no difference between similar SMT and conventional LEDs, it is stricly a matter of ease of mounting....so it you have a good mounting scheme for conventional LEDs...use em lol